Kari and I decided a while back to switch our phone and internet service from AT&T to Comcast. While it costs a little more, we’d grown to believe that the quality of service, not to mention the significantly faster internet, would be well worth the price. I got online to order service and expected to soon have the service up and running.
Boy, was I wrong. What followed was the most comically ridiculous series of errors I’ve ever experienced. Time after time Comcast consistently shot itself in the foot. Here is the summary of misadventures that I emailed to Comcast customer support this morning:
- I initially tried to schedule installation online. It consistently got to the “Live Chat” portion of the process, and the website would report an error. I tried this numerous times on many different days and times using 4 different web browsers (calling on the phone was not as convenient).
- Eventually, when I got a person on the phone (after winding through a ridiculous automation system), the person on the other end went through the process only to find that the scheduling system was down, and I would have to call another time and start the process all over.
- @ComcastCares on Twitter had me send a detailed email we_can_help@cable.comcast.com, and the recipient of that email passed me on to a local rep.
- The rep called and left a single message on my cell phone. When I returned her call, I got her voicemail and left a message, but I never heard from her again. She never called me back.
- I called the toll-free number back 2 days later and scheduled and installation appointment for February 27 (8-11), which at the time was 2 weeks away. February 27 came, and the installation people came out to the house 30 minutes before the scheduled window was to close. They said they could not install because my house (30 years old) had never been wired for cable TV or it needed to be rewired, and they didn’t have the right supplies. (Don’t you think it would have made sense to find out what was needed BEFORE coming out?)
- We rescheduled for the following Saturday, March 6. I later received a phone call saying that March 6 couldn’t work because Comcast could not transfer the number until March 8. (That would’ve been very interesting for me if the February 27 installation had gone as planned.)
- I rescheduled the installation a third time for Wednesday, March 10. I had to take off from work to wait for them. I wouldn’t have minded if the installation had actually taken place. Instead, all I did was wait until a Comcast rep called me at 10:55am (5 minutes before the 8-11am window closed). She said that the installer was stuck at another job and wouldn’t be here on time. Tough. I had an 11:30 meeting that I had to be at. I wasted 3 hours of my morning waiting. I couldn’t wait anymore. I was so irritated, I just told her to cancel the installation altogether because I have no faith that it will ever happen.
If any one (or even two) of these problems had happened, I could understand. Problems come up, and you deal with them and move on, but this has become ridiculous. I’d like to say I think you can help me, but I have to wonder whether any subsequent attempts will be met with yet another problem. None of this has instilled any confidence in Comcast.
Now, I’m not one to complain about customer service. I understand that large companies such as Comcast (especially those that outsources a lot of its labor) can have a hard to making everything go completely smooth, but this became worthy of the Three Stooges. I appreciate the concern shown by @ComcastCares and @ComcastMelissa over Twitter, but all they did from a practical standpoint was direct me to an email address that may or may not have helped. If I didn’t know better, I’d think Comcast didn’t want my business! I’m seriously considering obliging them and just sticking with slow AT&T.

Then, I began to think. I thought about how many pundits said that it wouldn’t replace a laptop or desktop computer. I thought about how I generally don’t like to sit down at the desk with the iMac to work on that computer. I thought about how lately I’ve preferred to do as much of my computing tasks as possible on my iPhone because the OS is just so fun and easy to use, despite the small screen and virtual thumb keyboard. Slowly, it began to occur to me that the iPad might be exactly what I am looking for. It provides the iPhone OS that I love with a larger, more useful screen. The multitouch, gesture-based UI is perfectly suited for such a device. It allows full, ten-fingered use of the iPhone OS’s virtual keyboard that I actually enjoy using. I even “realized” that I do more word processing than I thought I did, and the VGA video adapter means that I can connect the iPad to a projector for Keynote presentations. Suddenly, it occurred to me that the iPad wouldn’t be a replacement for my Nook or my iPhone. It might actually be a replacement for my desktop computer. Of course, it doesn’t have the power and capability of a full-featured computer, but the majority of my computing tasks (certainly my day-to-day activities) consisted of tasks that the iPad should be able to handle. The other 4-5% could be done on my now less important iMac. Now, the iPad is not without its faults. I really believe in order for it to be the kind of device I want it to be, it would have to have some way to access Hulu, which it a Flash-based site. Since neither the iPhone nor the iPad allows Flash (which I’m typically grateful for), neither can play video from Hulu. Right now, that’s my biggest problem with the iPad, but it’s by no means a deal-breaker.







